# Round 1: dealer's view All dealer-economics numbers below are ASSUMPTION from my experience, not sourced. ## 1. Verdict Good instinct (own the stock record, clean attribution), but as written a lot owner says "I already get this free on Marketplace, and now I type everything twice." The dashboard is the product risk; financing is the buyer risk. ## 2. Top 5 problems **1. Double entry kills the dashboard in about 3 weeks.** Owner lists on Marketplace, Kijiji and maybe AutoTrader already. A fourth place to update is not happening. Cars sell at 6 pm on a Saturday with cash on the hood; nobody opens an app. Your "mark sold" step is the whole attribution model and the plan admits it is make-or-break. *Fix:* make the dashboard the place that saves them work. One entry produces ready-to-paste listing text and the photo set for Marketplace, Kijiji and AutoTrader. Add "reply SOLD 4417" by SMS to the morning nudge. Dealers live in texts, not apps. Measure sold-lag as a metric from day 1. **2. "Why pay for ads when Marketplace is free?" is not answered.** You pitch ads; the owner hears "a vendor that sells me clicks". Marketplace leads are tire-kickers too, but they're free and he knows them. *Fix:* pitch the response and the proof, not the ads. "You miss evening and weekend messages and calls. We answer in a minute and show you which buyers showed up." Ad spend is the means. Lead with after-hours capture (missed-call text-back) because it works on the leads he already has. **3. Financing is why many buyers pick an independent, and v2 ignores it.** A large share of lot buyers (ASSUMPTION: a majority at buy-here-pay-here-ish lots) ask "what's the payment?" and "can I get approved?" before "is it available?". Back-end (finance reserve, warranty) is often as much gross as the car. An agent that just hands off financing sends the best-converting question to a text alert at 9 pm. *Fix:* collect a soft pre-qual (income range, down payment, employment, credit self-rating, trade yes/no) and deliver it as a deal sheet, no terms quoted. Keep the "no financing in ads" rule for Meta, but not in the agent flow. **4. Attribution will start arguments.** "Bought any car within 60 days" after first contact reads to a dealer as a trap. He also hates a vendor texting his customers 10 days after a visit ("Did you buy from X?"): if the deal fell through or the buyer is embarrassed about credit, he blames us. Walk-ins who also saw an ad, repeat customers, and people who were already on his Marketplace chat are all disputed. He will say "he was coming anyway." *Fix:* narrow the rule at first: a sale is ours only if the buyer was booked or chatted through us before first contact with the lot, same car or same-lot, 30 days. Get the dealer to approve the buyer-check text wording in advance and let him turn it off (CASL: still need a clean identification and unsubscribe). Pay on shows during the pilot (see 5), where there is no argument. **5. The pricing ladder asks a stranger to commit before he trusts us.** Month 1 free is good. Then C$299-499 plus ad spend (C$25-40/day is about C$750-1,200 a month) is C$1,100-1,700 a month all in, before he has seen one sale credited. Cost of one car in front-end gross at a small lot is often C$1,500-3,000 (ASSUMPTION), so "one extra car covers it" is true only if that car is real and credited. After 8 weeks of nothing, he blames us, not the market. *Fix:* keep month 1 free. For months 2-3, charge a low base (C$149-199) plus a per-show fee (C$25-50, ASSUMPTION), and add the per-sale fee only once the buyer-check matches. Put a stop-loss in writing: "if no credited sale by week 8, you pay no fee." Owners respect a vendor who carries risk. ## Also hurting you (lower rank) - **Test-drive slots.** The owner is often the only salesperson and is with a buyer or at auction. Rigid slots mean no-shows and an angry owner. Use "come anytime between X and Y, call this number" with a confirmation SMS. - **Phone is the lead.** Used-car buyers still call. The forwarding number is right; add missed-call text-back, since one missed call at 7 pm is a lost deal. - **Negotiation.** "What's your best price?" is the most common message. Agent must say "come see it" without sounding like a robot or hiding the all-in price (Ontario requires it). - **Half-day audit** is real cost (about 60 cars x 12 photos), and photos are the thing dealers hate doing. Sell it as a free photo shoot, not "audit". - **Ad account ownership.** If we run ads under our account, he'll worry he can't leave. Use his Page and his ad account with us as partner. ## 3. What to keep - Stock-matched ads for real cars; photos sell used cars. - Dashboard as the system of record. If he uses it, attribution works. It is the right bet. - All-in prices, no invented availability or terms. This is what keeps dealers out of regulator trouble. - Phone-first, VIN auto-fill, one-tap sold. - The 8-week count and written fail rules. Honest and buyable. - "Don't mention financing in Meta ads" is correct for Meta's restrictions. ## 4. What the plan is missing: the deal sheet Dealers will pay for pre-qualified buyers, not for leads. Every conversation ends with a one-screen **deal sheet** pushed to his phone: car, buyer name and number, down payment, monthly budget, rough income and job, credit self-rating, trade-in (make, model, year, km, 3 photos), when they can come. He taps "call" or "send to lender." Why dealers want it: - A subprime buyer arrives with a rough idea of what he can get approved for. The owner skips the first 20 minutes. - The trade-in photos give a rough number before the visit (we don't appraise, he does). - It is the data his lenders ask for anyway, so it plugs into how he already works (Canadian subprime lenders are an ASSUMPTION I know from experience, not sourced). - It also gives us attribution evidence: a buyer record with real finance details that the dealer later has to enter against a sale. Privacy: collect only what is necessary, say why, store it carefully. Do not run credit ourselves. This is a data-collection step, not lending.