# Round 2: dealer's seat Dealer numbers are ASSUMPTION from experience. ## Rebuttals and positions **(a) Interface.** Product is right that the web dashboard is the wrong daily tool; skeptic is wrong that it is "the paid product". No owner pays C$399 for an inventory app. He pays for buyers who show up. But SMS-only is wrong too: my morning text "Still have the CR-V? Y/SOLD" works, my price edits and photos don't. Position: SMS for daily (Y / SOLD / HOLD / who bought), one phone web form for add and edit, and we, not the dealer, own the admin view. Skeptic's 5-day sold-marking trial is the best idea in Round 1; I'd run it by SMS, not a spreadsheet. **(b) Financing.** I stand by it, but I concede scope. Product is right: no valuation, no lender integration. MVP version is three extra questions (down payment, monthly budget, financing yes/no) plus trade-in photos, delivered as a text to the owner. That's a form field, not a feature. Full deal sheet and lender hand-off: later. **(c) Week 4 / week 8.** Growth is right: C$500 buys about 12-25 leads, 1-2 shows. "6 booked, 3 shows" is hope. Week 4 decides process and dealer behaviour: sold-marking, response time, no wrong answers, owner picks up the booked buyers. Week 8 decides demand. Where growth is wrong: a 10-day burst at C$60-80 a day is C$700 on one lot; fine, but a dealer sees that as a bigger bill, so the pilot fee waiver must cover it. **(d) Pricing and pilot payer.** Skeptic's labour math is the real killer; I concede the fee is not the point. Who pays in the pilot: we pay ad spend, up to a cap (about C$600), in month 1. A dealer gives a stranger his Page and card only after he's seen shows. Then base C$149-199 plus C$25-50 per show, per-sale fee only after the buyer-check matches. Stop-loss in writing: no credited sale by week 8, no fee. Skeptic's "written C$299+ commitment" is the wrong kill test; owners don't sign before results. Ask for a verbal yes at the demo and a signed month 2 only on a result. **(e) Attribution.** Product's manual version wins for the pilot: Friday 10-minute call from our lead sheet. Agree. But "who bought it" in the app is dead; the SMS "SOLD 4417" reply gets there. Drop the 60-day any-car rule for the pilot. Credit the sale if our booking code or lead phone matches within 30 days, either car. The auto buyer-check text: dealer pre-approves wording, or we skip it. A vendor texting his customers is how we lose the account. **(f) Audit vs text-the-car.** Product's text-the-car intake is the best idea of this round, but I'd not bet the pilot on it. Owners hate photographing, and photo quality is what Meta ads depend on. Position: one visit, top 15 cars, we shoot them (and pitch it as the free photo shoot). Text-the-car for the rest, built if we win week 2. Concede the full half-day audit doesn't scale. ## Concessions - Marketplace is free. Skeptic's test works: ask "how many leads a week, and what would you pay for 10 more?" - Growth: week 4 cannot prove demand. - Product: cut call tracking, auto reports, auto buyer-check, VIN automation from the pilot. - Skeptic: legal review of the price template before ads go live. ## Final top 5 must-haves for v3 1. Sold-marking by SMS reply, run as a 5-day trial before ads, with a 24-hour target. 2. Car page with all-in price; agent facts come from database fields, never typed by the model. 3. Fast response plus a missed-call text-back on the tracked number. Phone is the lead. 4. Deal info on every lead: down payment, budget, trade-in yes/no and photos, sent to the owner as one text. 5. Free lot photo shoot of the top 15 cars, done by us, plus a verbal fee commitment at the demo and a signed fee only after results. ## Kill criterion If the dealer marks fewer than 70% of sales within 24 hours in the 5-day SMS trial, stop. No dashboard fix will save it, because attribution and stock freshness both depend on it.