# R2 Growth: rebuttals Numbers remain ASSUMPTION unless sourced. ## To the skeptic: "ads lose to free Marketplace, make them a templated add-on" Half right. Ads must be incremental, and hand-built campaigns per dealer do not scale. But demoting ads kills the pitch. A dealer who already posts free will not pay C$399 for an inventory app, since Marketplace is his inventory app. The skeptic's own table shows AI chat selling at C$500-1,200/rooftop because it sits on traffic; ours has no traffic without ads. Marketplace is also a ceiling, not a rival: it reaches people already looking at his listings, ads reach the rest of the radius. So: keep paid demand as the core promise, but make it a template (one campaign structure, one creative kit, 10% transcript sampling after week 4). Dealer owns the ad account; we are partner. That answers cost-to-serve without dropping the revenue driver. ## Positions on the live fights **(a) Dealer interface.** Product is right: SMS for sold/hold/still-here, one mobile add-car form, leads in a shared sheet. Dealer's fix helps too: generate paste-ready Marketplace text. The skeptic's "dashboard is the product" is the weakest claim here: no sold-habit, no product. Full dashboard waits for pilot evidence. **(b) Financing.** Include a lite deal sheet now: cash or finance, down payment, monthly budget, trade-in yes/no with 3 photos, arrival time. No income, employment or credit self-rating in the MVP (privacy risk, and it drifts toward Meta's credit category on landing pages). Full pre-qual is v4 after counsel reads it. The lite sheet is what makes the booking worth the dealer's time. **(c) Week 4.** Concede my own R1 was too soft on one point: week 4 should still contain a floor. Week 4 decides process and dealer behaviour (answer time, zero wrong answers, sold-by-text rate, dealer reacts to alerts) plus a demand floor. The demand verdict is week 8, after a burst of C$60-80/day. At C$30/day, week 4 cannot read CPL reliably. **(d) Pricing.** Concede cost-to-serve to the skeptic and fee structure to the dealer. Month 1: no fee, but dealer pays ad spend from his own card on his own account, so he has skin in the game. Months 2-3: C$149-199 base plus C$25-50 per show, with a written stop-loss: no credited sale by week 8, no fee. Per-sale fee only after the buyer check matches. **(e) Attribution.** Narrow the rule (dealer's version): buyer first contacted us before the lot, same lot, 30 days, not the 60-day "any car". Pilot pays on shows. Do "who bought it" by Friday phone call (product). Buyer-check text goes out only with dealer-approved wording and counsel review; skeptic is right that it carries risk. **(f) Intake.** Product's text-the-car intake wins as the permanent flow. But the first dealer gets a free half-day photo shoot of the top 15 cars: ad creative lives or dies on photos and a short walkaround video, so I will not skip it. Sell it as a shoot, not an audit. ## Concessions - Week-4 targets as written (6 bookings, 3 shows) are wrong; the skeptic's floor of 10 leads and 2 shows in the first two ad weeks is the right kind of line. - Dealer's point that the plan must lead with after-hours capture, not "leads", is correct. - Product is right to start Meta business verification and SMS registration on day 1. ## Top 5 must-haves for v3 1. Written week-4 gates on process and a demand floor; verdict on cost per booked visit at week 8 after about C$1,500 total spend. 2. Dealer-owned ad account, one broad ad set, optimise for link click or page view, ad -> car page with one-tap text/call, vertical walkaround videos. 3. Meta vehicle catalog feed generated from stock (sold cars drop out of ads automatically), plus retargeting of page visitors. 4. Pitch: "we answer after hours and prove who showed up"; month-1 no fee, stop-loss in writing. 5. "How did you find us" field and a new-vs-existing-contact split, to measure what Marketplace does not cover. ## Kill criterion After C$1,000 of spend over 14 or more ad days: under 25 real leads (text, call or form with phone), or cost per booked visit above C$300, or fewer than half of booked buyers new to the lot. Then drop paid demand as the core and pivot to the templated add-on.