# Round 3: Skeptic on organic-first All numbers ASSUMPTION unless a URL is given. ## 1. Real vs fantasy **Real:** Google Business Profile (GBP) posts and calls, the dealer's own Page and walkaround video, paste-ready listing text, missed-call text-back, the agent answering inbound messages. **Fantasy in 8 weeks:** - **SEO.** New-domain pages for "used SUVs under C$20k in [town]" take months to rank and compete with AutoTrader. Mass-produced thin pages also risk Google's spam rules on scaled content (from memory, not searched). Park them until week 8+. - **Organic reach.** A small lot's Page probably has under 1,000 followers; an unboosted post reaches a small slice of them. One lot may yield 5-15 organic leads in 8 weeks, too few to judge a channel. - **Filming.** "The dealer films every car" will not hold. Expect under half of cars with video by week 4. Photos stay the base. - **Platform plumbing.** Marketplace has no listing API, so paste-text stays manual. Inbound Page/Instagram messages need Meta app review and have reply-window limits (not verified). Auto-posting Reels needs the Instagram publishing API (not checked). Meta banned general-purpose AI chatbots from WhatsApp from 15 Jan 2026; sales and support bots stay allowed but Meta defines the line ([TechCrunch](https://techcrunch.com/2025/10/18/whatssapp-changes-its-terms-to-bar-general-purpose-chatbots-from-its-platform), [respond.io](https://respond.io/blog/whatsapp-general-purpose-chatbots-ban)). Our bot is business-function, so low risk, but not zero. **Legal:** - **Match alerts.** CASL implied consent for an inquiry lasts 6 months, 2 years after a purchase ([ISED](https://ised-isde.canada.ca/site/canada-anti-spam-legislation/en/node/7)). It is still a commercial message: sender identity, unsubscribe, and a consent record are needed. Dealer-approved wording only. - **Google reviews.** Incentives for reviews count as fake engagement, and Google also prohibits review gating, meaning asking only happy customers ([Google](https://support.google.com/business/answer/14114287), third-party summaries). So no "referral reward", no "rate us only if satisfied". Send the request to every buyer, same wording. ## 2. Channel order for 3-4 weeks Build: GBP post per car, one walkaround reel posted to the dealer's Page and IG after Approve, paste text, missed-call text-back, car pages (few, indexable, honest). Add: boost at C$5-10/day (dealer-paid) on the best reel. Cut or delay: inventory SEO pages, match alerts (until 20+ past inquirers exist), review requests (after the first 3 sales), Page DM/IG inbound, TikTok, Shorts. ## 3. Are we a cheap social agency? Close to it. Agencies sell effort, churn fast, and cannot prove sales. Better than agency: content is templated software, and the sold record proves results. Worse: outcomes are then hostage to platform reach and our dealer's filming. Keep the pitch on answering and stock, not on posting. ## 4. Measurement and kill line Per channel: tracked phone number or UTM link, a "how did you find us" field, GBP calls and direction taps, and share of leads new to the lot. **Week-8 kill line for organic as the core:** under 15 attributable organic leads or under 3 bookings (with at most C$100 of boost spend), or under 50% of cars with video by week 4. Then organic is a free extra, and the paid product is the stock-and-answering service. ## 5. Effect on cost and the 3 h cap Each channel adds work: platform permissions per dealer (Page/IG/GBP verification, roughly 1-2 h), approval chasing, reel processing (about C$1-3 per reel), reply drafts. Without automation that is plus 2-4 h/month, so the cap breaks. Rule: every channel must be one-tap for the dealer and zero-touch for us, or it is cut. Count setup of each channel as paid setup, not monthly hours. ## Kill criteria - Hours per dealer above 4 in any month after month 1. - Dealer approves fewer than half of drafted reels or posts. - Any CASL complaint, Google review restriction, or Meta restriction on a dealer account. - Week 8: organic leads or bookings below the line above.